Members.dev vs MemberClicks
Members.dev is a modern, lightweight membership engine for small-to-medium organizations that value speed and flexibility. MemberClicks is an ERP built for large associations and chambers that require a traditional, all-in-one suite.
A note on our methodology
Have you ever seen a comparison page where the company writing the comparison doesn't come out on top? Neither have we.
That's why we want to outline our approach openly: the purpose of this page is to explain why Members.dev is superior to MemberClicks. We're experts in the membership software space, but we are biased, so we'll keep it factual and let you make the decision that's right for you. For some of you, MemberClicks will be a better fit—we want to explain when that might be the case, and when Members.dev is a more suitable choice.
When to use Members.dev vs MemberClicks
Based on our latest review (May 2026) of Members.dev and MemberClicks' features:
- You want a modern, professional interface that feels like 2026, not 2010
- You want membership software which is flexible, and easily integrated into your existing website or app
- You want a transparent, flat-rate pricing model without enterprise 'hidden' fees
- You want 1:1 dedicated support from a small team
- You want benefit tracking and entitlement logic
- You are a large trade association, Chamber of Commerce, or other large organization requiring a legacy association management system
- You want built-in modules to help manage job boards and committee management
- You have a significant budget for long-term implementation and enterprise training
About Members.dev
Members.dev is a modern membership engine designed for flexibility. While traditional systems force you to work within their rigid templates, we built Members.dev to support associations of all sizes with a focus on data integrity and user experience.
- Modern User Experience: Our admin dashboard and customer portal are designed to be intuitive and beautiful. If you want to present a professional, modern brand to your members, Members.dev is for you.
- Customization: From custom fields and forms on membership profiles to fully configurable membership products, and support for multiple sub-organizations, Members.dev can support complex needs.
- API-First Extensibility: Membership systems shouldn't be silos. Our extensive REST API and webhooks allow you to link your membership data to physical access systems, POS software, or custom apps effortlessly.
- Benefit Tracking: Members.dev excels at managing entitlements, like tracking usage against free pass quotas or multi-tiered memberships linked to credits - which traditional systems often do not include.
- Enterprise Features without bloat: We include SSO, SAML integration, audit logs, and multi-organization support (chapters/franchises) without the clunky interface of legacy software.
- Dedicated Support: We are a tightly knit team. You get dedicated, 1:1 support from experts who understand the code, not just a call center.
About MemberClicks
MemberClicks is a comprehensive Association Management Software (AMS). It is designed to be a system of record for professional associations, combining a database with heavy-duty tools for events, learning management (LMS), and job boards. There are two editions of MemberClicks' software: MC Professional (from $4,500/year) and MC Trade (from $3,500/year).
MC Professional is designed for organizations which have individual people as members. MC Trade is designed for when your members are organizations (e.g. businesses, chambers of commerce, trade associations). While they are distinct software products, the functionality is very similar. Both include a member directory, automated dues and reminders, email automation, a member portal, and reporting tools. MC Trade includes the ability to create custom structures to link employees and employers, or parent companies with subsidiaries.
Feature Comparison
| Members.dev | MemberClicks | |
|---|---|---|
| Features | ||
| Membership Database | ||
| Custom Fields | ||
| Digital Membership Cards | Early Access (contact support) | In-app only |
| Website Builder | Integrate portal into existing site/app | |
| Member Portal | ||
| eCommerce store | Via Member Portal | |
| Committee Management Module | ||
| Learning Management (LMS) | Via API Integration | Add-on |
| Subscription & billing | ||
| Configurable Membership Products | ||
| Configurable Payment Provider | Personify Payments | |
| Group / Family memberships | ||
| Automatic Renewals, Invoicing and Reminders | ||
| Benefit Entitlement Tracking | Limited | |
| Advanced features | ||
| API and webhooks | Legacy SOAP/REST mix | |
| Multi-organization support | MC Trade only | |
| Third-party integrations | Using the API and webhooks | MailChimp, Accounting, WordPress, Zapier |
| Support | Dedicated account manager for all customers | Phone, email, and chat support |
| Custom Onboarding | Included for all | High-cost professional service |
| Pricing | ||
| Pricing Model | Flat rate | Contract-based |
| Transaction fee | 3.0–1.5% | Contact MemberClicks for details |
| Starts at | From $19/month | From $4,500/year (MC Professional); From $3,500/year (MC Trade) |
| Free trial | 30 days | Negotiated with sales |
| Sales motion | Start today, or book a demo | Sales team led |
Which platform is better for Multi-organization and Chapter Support?
While MC Trade is for associations whose customers are organizations (e.g. businesses, chambers of commerce, trade associations), its architecture is not designed to support those organizations having their own members/membership programs.
Members.dev is built for true multi-tenancy. You can create sub-organizations that operate as independent entities, each with its own dedicated admin dashboard and member database, while still maintaining global oversight. There are no restrictions on whether a member is a person or an organization, and you can have a mix of both. Alternatively, you can create groups of users, such as a committee, or company.
MemberClicks offers chapter management, but mainly as filtered views of the member directory. While this works for reporting, it lacks true autonomy that chapters often require.
How extendable are Members.dev and MemberClicks?
Members.dev is built for the modern web. Every piece of data is accessible via a high-performance API, making it an ideal membership engine to power an organization today, especially if they have a custom-built website or mobile app. We focus on being the best at membership and letting you sync that data with your favorite specialized tools.
MemberClicks aims to be your entire office. Because it includes its own website builder, email tool, and event module, it is less focused on external extensibility. While they do have an API, it is primarily designed to move data into other enterprise systems rather than powering a real-time custom user experience.
Can I migrate my data from MemberClicks?
Yes. Moving from a legacy AMS like MemberClicks to Members.dev is a common path for organizations looking to modernize.
MemberClicks supports data exports, though their database schemas can be complex. Members.dev provides white-glove migration and onboarding to ensure your member history, renewal dates, and custom fields are mapped correctly to our modern system. Message support@members.dev to begin a migration audit.
Want to see Members.dev in action?
Book a call to discuss your setup and get a tailored demo.
